Judge Cannon Knew Precisely What She Was Doing
Billionaire bought justices and the wealthy few are striving to rule over us. Join us to advocate for Freedom over Fascism.
Please share our Freedom Over Fascism publication with friends, family members, and community members.
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: July 18, 2024 Democracy 21
On Monday, federal district court Judge Aileen Cannon dismissed the Mar-a-Lago classified documents criminal case facing former President Donald Trump.
Cannon did not rule on the merits of the case itself. The 37 felony charges brought against Trump by Special Counsel Jack Smith in June 2023 presented a powerful case that seemed “open and shut.”
Instead, Cannon ruled that Smith’s appointment as a Justice Department special counsel was unconstitutional – the only such ruling by any court, including the Supreme Court, that has considered the same question in numerous cases over decades.
After various moves over many months that delayed the case, Judge Cannon has now ensured the case will not be heard before the election, if ever.
Smith is appealing Cannon’s decision, but the damage has already been done. Trump, if elected in November, will quickly instruct his Attorney General to dismiss the case.
Let’s be real. Judge Cannon knew precisely what she was doing. Her performance in this case has all the appearance of a biased judge out to deep-six the case and give flowers to Trump.
For some observers, Judge Cannon’s performance was an audition for a promotion. Following the case dismissal on Monday, MAGA Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-FL) called her “future Supreme Court Justice Cannon.”
While some have labeled Judge Cannon’s delays of the case the result of inexperience and/or incompetence, Cannon’s performance appears intentional and designed simply to protect Trump.
The slow-walking of the case started when Judge Cannon interfered with the Special Counsel’s development of its case. This led to Judge Cannon being strongly rebuked by the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals.
First, the three-judge appeals panel reversed Cannon’s appointment of a special master to review the classified documents and temporarily suspended the Justice Department’s use of the documents. The panel consisted of three conservative judges: two Trump appointees and one G.W. Bush appointee.
Then in a second case, an 11th Circuit panel again reversed Judge Cannon, stating she abused her discretion when she claimed she had “jurisdiction to block the United States from using lawfully seized records in a criminal investigation.”
The panel ruled that Cannon’s decision violated “clear” law, “would be a radical reordering of our caselaw,” and “would violate bedrock separation-of-powers limitations.”
At one point, Judge Cannon wrote that Trump’s position as a former President put him in “a league of [his] own.” This, of course, violates a foundational principle in our country that no one, not even a former President, is above the law.
The 11th Circuit forcefully dismissed Cannon’s attempt to “carve out an unprecedented exception in our law for former Presidents.”
Delaying the trial, however, apparently wasn’t enough for Judge Cannon. So, when the opportunity arose, she made an unprecedented decision that Smith’s appointment was unconstitutional and dismissed the entire case.
Cannon’s opinion reeks of Trump bias.
Cannon rejected a core finding made by the Supreme Court in U.S. v. Nixon, in 1974, that the Watergate special prosecutor was properly appointed by the Attorney General. Cannon wrongly dismissed the ruling as “dicta” – that is, only a comment not necessary to resolve the case and therefore not binding on her.
Absurdly, to support her opinion, Cannon three times quoted dicta from Justice Clarence Thomas’s self-indulgent concurring opinion in the presidential immunity case. The Thomas concurrence was not joined by any other Justice and had nothing to do with the immunity issue before the Court.
Thomas appears to have written his opinion expressly to guide Cannon and she went for it – hook, line, and sinker.
Judge Cannon in her opinion ignored two important D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals rulings that upheld the constitutionality of two different special counsel appointments. Cannon wrote that she wasn’t going to pay attention to decisions from other Circuit Court jurisdictions.
According to former Acting Solicitor General Neal Katyal, Judge Cannon’s “decision to throw out serious national-security criminal charges in the classified documents case against Donald Trump is legally unsupported, ignores decades of precedent, and is deeply dangerous.”
Katyal, who wrote the Justice Department’s regulations for the appointment of special counsels, continued: “We’ve had special counsels and special prosecutors since at least the time of President Ulysses Grant after the Civil War. That is for a simple reason: We need a system to police high-level executive branch wrongdoing, and the system can’t be run by the President and his appointees alone.”
Cannon, by all appearances has shown herself to be a biased judge who ignored the seriousness of the national security case pending before her and went rogue to protect former President Trump.
TRUMPWATCH
Republican Party Is Trump’s Now. Critics Wary His Quest For Power Will Go Unchecked. – Reuters
How Clarence Thomas Helped Thwart Prosecution Of Trump In Docs Case – The Guardian
Special Counsel Appeals Dismissal Of Trump Classified Docs Case – CNN
Three Flaws In The Supreme Court’s Decision On Presidential Criminal Immunity
SCOTUS’s immunity decision “suffers from shallow reasoning, lack of historical support, and distortion of legal precedent.” – Andrew Weissman, Just Security
VANCEWATCH
Why Donald Trump Picked J.D. Vance For Vice President
“The Ohio senator is an attack dog for the former President, but he is also something more emergent and interesting: he is the fuse that Trump lit.” – The New Yorker
Trump Chooses A VP Who Would Do What Mike Pence Wouldn’t – The Washington Post
J.D. Vance’s Radical Plan To Build A Government Of Trump Loyalists – Vox
MEANWHILE, ON CAPITOL HILL
Congress is on recess.
Senate And House Launch Investigations Of Security Failure At Trump Rally – Roll Call
Sen. Bob Menendez (D-NJ) found guilty on all 16 counts of taking bribes in cash and gold and acting as Egypt’s foreign agent (Associated Press) … said he will resign (NBC News) … or maybe not (CBS News) … “The arrogance went to his head” (Politico)
ELECTIONS ’24: “IT’S GETTING TO THE POINT WHERE IT’S NO FUN ANYMORE”
With apologies to CSNY
The Campaign Is Getting Real For Political Donors
5 takeaways from Monday’s FEC deadline – Politico
⮞⮞⮞ The GOP – The Convention And More
How Trump Dominated His Own Party On A New GOP Platform – The New York Times
Indicted Election Deniers From Several States Are Republican Convention Delegates – National Public Radio
Musk Pledges To Give $45M A Month To Trump Super PAC
“Potentially crossing into hundreds of millions of dollars, Musk’s promised spending would be unprecedented.” – The Hill
Republicans Can’t Stop Lying About Voter Fraud – Francis Wilkinson, Bloomberg
Dark Money Just Got Darker: Wall Street Helped Fund Project 2025
“Financial giants are helping wealthy donors funnel cash to Project 2025 and other extremist causes with zero transparency or tax repercussions.” – The Lever
⮞⮞⮞ The Dems – Pressure Builds
Top Dems Now Believe Biden Will Exit – Axios
Dems Persuade Party To Slow Biden’s Nomination As Discontent Persists – The New York Times
House Dems Pull In Big Fundraising Haul As They Confront Tricky Campaign – NBC News
⮞⮞⮞ The Rest
Kennedy And West Third-Party Ballot Drives Are Pushed By Secretive Groups And Republican Donors – Associated Press
Resources: Access online version of release HERE
Please share our Freedom Over Fascism publication with friends, family members, and community members.